Bless You Boys: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: The 2009-2010 Card Chronicle Big East basketball preview

A Starting Catcher Rotation?

As disappointing as this season has been for the Detroit Tigers, with games such as last night's that you just can't bear to see through to the finish, you can't say that it's a boring team to follow.  Because almost every day, there's some off-the-field announcement regarding a roster move, position change, or other such shuffle that Jim Leyland employs as he tries something - anything - to get his squad to try and play up to expectations.  Different third basemen, different left fielders, different designated hitters, different set-up men in the bullpen, etc.  Jimmy's trying everything! 

Maybe we can start a recurring series of posts here, titled "What Will Jim Try Today?"  (I reserve the right to think about it.  And also to consider wristband merchandising opportunities.)  Yesterday's installment of "WWJTT?" concerned the Tigers' catching situation, as Leyland announced that Pudge Rodriguez would now be getting every other day off, alternating behind the plate with Brandon Inge

Well, why not?  Pudge's numbers have been in steady decline since mid-May (when he was batting a season-high .278/.324/.413), now hitting .245/.286/.349, which is the lowest his average has been all season.  Leyland believes that's partially due to Pudge playing so many games (52) at catcher, and he might just be right about that.  But this might be a chicken-vs.-egg scenario, as well.  Is Pudge's energy being sapped by having to squat behind the plate so frequently?  Or are his batting skills just diminishing, and the only reason he's really in the lineup is because of his defensive talents?

Early in the season, many of us were wondering why Pudge was catching so frequently when Leyland had previously been so conscious of giving him some rest.  A big reason for that, of course, was that the Tigers really had no viable back-up at the position, especially while Inge had to be dragged behind the plate kicking and screaming.

Now, Inge not only has realized that catching isn't so bad, but has also seemed to embrace the possibility (inevitability?) that he'll be Detroit's starting catcher next season, with Pudge moving on to the next team willing to give him a contract.  And that is surely another motivating factor behind Leyland's decision.  (It certainly can't be because he thinks Inge is a better hitter than Pudge.)  The Tigers have to figure out if Inge really can be an everyday catcher again.  And if they get their answer in the affirmative sooner rather than later, maybe Pudge even becomes trade bait for a team in need of catching help. 

At Mack Avenue Tigers, Kurt beat me to the other point I was going to make about this decision.  This might be the first indication that Leyland is beginning to realize the 2008 season is a lost cause.  If Detroit was 10 games over .500, would he be flip-flopping catchers?  Even if Pudge was hitting as badly as he is right now?  Maybe Leyland would try to get Pudge some more rest, but to this extent? 

But perhaps the key words in Leyland's announcement yesterday were "for a while."  He didn't say the Tigers would rotate catchers for the rest of the season.  And as Billfer and Lee remind us, Leyland has changed his mind frequently after making such decisions.  Really, the only change he's stuck with is playing Miguel Cabrera at first base.  This could all change next week.  Hell, maybe we should expect to see Carlos Guillen playing catcher at some point.  He's already played almost everywhere else, trying to accommodate Leyland's various whims.

0 recs  |  Comment 1 comment

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Rebuilding

I think The Tigers almost have to trade Pudge. It isn’t because he’s not hitting and it isn’t because the season is lost (though it may be). It’s because when he walks at the end of this season we won’t be able to get a draft pick for him unless he’s offered arbitration, which he would surely accept. In order to gain something for his departure in addition to clearing his salary, he has to be moved. The problem is there are few teams who would actually trade for him. Most teams who need catchers are out of contention already and probably wouldn’t trade for 2 months of Pudge just because they have a hole at that position. The only fit I can think of is The Mets who also don’t have a great situation, but at the very least Minaya might like the idea of re-signing the great Ivan Rodriguez at the end of the season.

I also think we should trade Renteria and let Hollimon and Santiago work out some shared time at short. Many would see this move and trading Pudge as giving up on the season, but losing the two worst hitters on the team (Pudge: .635 OPS, Renteria .681 OPS) and their salaries I think would be a step in the right direction.

by MacRae on Jun 10, 2008 4:20 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

"Bless You Boys" was the catchphrase used by former Detroit sportscaster Al Ackerman when reporting a winning Tigers score.
Start posting about the Tigers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Knights-09_small
Disenchanted Blue Jays Fan Looking For A New Team
Capt
MLB in the Community
Snapshot_20090927_small
The Anti-Climactic Flamethrower...
000tigs_small
Binge's buddy--Noah Biorkman
Tiger_s_game_1_small
Tigers Top 20 Prospects
Sifl_and_olly_small
The Offseason Twitch Outpost.
Dsc05841_1__small
Congratulations to Curtis Granderson
Detroit-tigers-logo_small
This Year in Baseball Awards-MLB.com
Dsc05841_1__small
Television question
Small
According to Twitter Scott Sizemore fractured his tibula Thursday

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Ian_bedhead_small Ian Casselberry