Phillies Looking at Polanco to Play Third Base

by Ian Casselberry on Nov 13, 2009 9:00 AM EST in Hot Stove Comment 7 comments

Could Placido Polanco play third base for the Phillies next season?

The Philadelphia Inquirer's Jim Salisbury reports that Polanco is one of three players the National League champs are looking at to take over for Pedro Feliz. (Chone Figgins is out of their price range, apparently.)

Polanco played for the Phillies from 2002 to 2005, before coming to the Tigers in a trade for Ugueth Urbina. He was the Cardinals' primary third baseman from 2001 to 2002, and as part of the deal that send Scott Rolen to St. Louis, he took over for Rolen at that position. Overall, he played 95 games at third for the Phillies before getting moved over to second base.

Despite just winning a Gold Glove for his play at second base, Salisbury reports that Polanco is willing to move to third base if it's for a playoff contender. The Phillies would prefer to sign Polanco to a one-or-two year contract, close to the $4.6 million he made this year with Detroit.

You'd think Polanco could get a raise (even if it's a small one), given the season he just had, along with the market for second basemen. But playing for a team that could make another World Series run would obviously have an appeal.

Looking at this through Tiger-striped glasses, however, watching Polanco play third base for another team would drive me temporarily nuts. I understand that his career in Detroit is likely over. That's not my problem. I think letting Scott Sizemore take over at second next year is the right baseball move.

But near the trade deadline, it appeared that the Tigers were looking at players who could possibly fill in for the increasingly aching and injured Brandon Inge at third base. Guys such as Marco Scutaro and Freddy Sanchez. A solution may have already been on their roster, yet the option was never even discussed. Would the Tigers' late-season offense have had a bit more punch, had Polanco been moved over to third, with Ramon Santiago taking over at second? Or perhaps giving Sizemore the September call-up he deserved?

Maybe Detroit thought their defense at third would suffer. But the Phillies sure seem to think they'd be okay with Polanco over there.

0 recs | Comment 7 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

If he goes somewhere, I'd prefer NL

That’d reduce the number of times I’ll cry next season.

2100 Woodward and Twitter

by john.kmiecik on Nov 13, 2009 9:57 AM EST reply actions

I don't like the Phillies, but I'd rather have him there than with the Twins

Tigers Amateur Analysis

by SabreRoseTiger on Nov 13, 2009 10:00 AM EST up reply actions

Amen to that

The only thing worse then losing a favorite player is losing him to a division rival. The Yanks and Red Sox would suck too so the NL is the least painful option if we have to say goodbye to Polly or any of the other players who Dombrowski is listening to offers for.

by Sutelc on Nov 13, 2009 12:44 PM EST up reply actions

I guess Polanco was too valuable at 2nd.

Santiago and Sizemore at short and 2nd, respectively, would have been a big gamble. Moving Polanco to 3rd would put a nice glove over there, but it left the middle with two inexperienced guys. As often as we were cursed with the DP last season, we were also blessed by it, too, and we can thank Polly for that.

by NCDee on Nov 13, 2009 1:32 PM EST reply actions

something I've never really understood...

is why Santiago never got some chances at 3rd? His glove is good enough for sure and he definitely has the arm to make the long throw to first.

Inge obviously needed a backup and nobody else was cutting it. Ramon should’ve gotten a chance.

My Music: Some Sorta Giant
New Song: One Days Work

by madpoopz on Nov 13, 2009 4:55 PM EST reply actions

Make it happen, with caveat

Getting Polanco for Urbina was one of the best moves Dombro ever made. Hopefully Dave can make it happen, you know, with the Phillies taking Polanco and Willis for Utley and Lidge. He’s just got to serve them whatever he did back in ’05, (“More Phillie Fishbowl Punch? I made this batch special!”)

by Joshsteich on Nov 13, 2009 6:27 PM EST reply actions