This speaks to just how bad the Tigers were. The second team could be expected to have won what, 65 games, with those players at their peaks? That even sounds too much. 60 maybe?

And some of the guys on the first team aren't particularly good either. Bobby Higginson had two good seasons as a Tiger this decade (more last decade) but that earns him First Team honors (which I actually agree with, as I can't think of someone to put above him!)