Retraction to Today's Post on Tony Paul and the Detroit News
Earlier today, I wrote a post that attacked Tony Paul and the Detroit News for a collection of articles on Tigers general manager Dave Dombrowski. Essentially, I accused Paul of ripping off a similar series written by Kurt Mensching at Mack Avenue Tigers.
I've been informed by Mr. Paul that he was assigned to write his stories on Dombrowski more than a month ago, and the pieces were submitted to his editor in early November. Proof of this was provided from the e-mail that was used to send in the stories.
Before angrily typing out my post, I should've contacted Mr. Paul and inquired as to the origins of his series of articles. I made some rather inflammatory accusations, ones which everyone working in the traditional and new media should take very seriously. To say that I didn't give the author a chance to defend himself is more than a fair criticism.
Obviously, these are issues I'm defensive about. (Perhaps over-defensive is a better description.) Past tensions between independent blogs and traditional media have created a sensitivity over the years, one which I'm typically quick to act upon. (I concede that these tensions have become a tiresome issue, and I shouldn't have brought it into this community.) Kurt is also a friend and colleague, and the idea that his hard work may have been co-opted angered me. I let both of those factors affect my judgment.
I apologize to Tony Paul (and, in turn, the Detroit News) for any accusations that may have called his integrity into question. I should've extended him the same courtesy that I demanded he show toward Kurt (and the Tigers blogosphere at-large) earlier today. Coincidences do, in fact, occur. I also apologize to you, the BYB readers, for making such a production out of this.
0 recs |
16 comments
|
Comments
Even though
you possibly acted in haste, Ian, I believe you’re intentions were good. I think you were defending your friend and it was very noble of you to do so. I think no less of you and I would have probably done the same thing. It’s all good. I admire you for publicly apologizing, it takes “big ones” for someone to humble themselves and admit it when they feel they’ve made a mistake. You are a good person.
by Detroitchik on Dec 3, 2009 8:29 PM EST reply actions 2 recs
+1
It’s also nice to see that the Detroit News was willing to acknowledge you and allow you to correct the mistake yourself as opposed to using it as more evidence as “blogs are bad”.
All’s well that ends well.
President, Vice President and Secretary of the Casey Crosby Fanclub.
Quickly sorted and moving on
It’s not just in the baseball world that bloggers and “old media” butt heads. It’s rampant all over the place. Your reaction is understandable to anyone that’s been involved with it as long as you or Kurt have been. Outside a few detractors I don’t think anyone is going to fault you for your initial reaction
I’m glad to see this came to a quick and happy ending.
2100 Woodward and Twitter
Been there, done that
I had to do the same thing for Josh Lewin on a baseball newsgroup 10 years ago. I feel your pain.
"Order your soul; reduce your wants; live in charity; associate in Christian community; obey the laws; trust in Providence."
-Augustine
an honest misunderstanding...
You came to your comrades defense. No shame in that.
by rook34 on Dec 3, 2009 10:58 PM EST via mobile reply actions
Mad respect from madpoopz Ian...
It takes a true man to fess up to a mistake.
Just remember there is never any shame in coming to the defense of a friend.
My Music: Some Sorta Giant
My Blog: Inside A Head
Hey, it happens Ian. Had I been around I would’ve had the same reaction you would’ve. Given the number of times a news paper has ripped off an image from a Tigers blogger or info from a tigers blogger forces one to be jaded on their whole “taking-things-without-crediting-the-original-source” shtick.
And now at Beyond the Boxscore and Project Prospect!
Your reaction was understandable.
I, too, have seen this kind of thing happen all the time. And quite frankly, you wouldn’t see this kind of apologetic acknowledgment from the “real” journalists.
And Kurt’s analysis was better.
Come on Ian!
You’re a blogger, you’re not supposed to have “ethics”! Stand by your story!
/I kid, I kid, well done!
Disgusted!
This is the that best describes Tiger Fan right now! After years of being the laughing stock of the entire major professional sports world, now we Tiger Fans have to endure STUPID decisions!!
It takes a big person
to admit that they’re wrong. Classy, Ian.

by 














