Porcello and Perry Will Wear the D
Jim Leyland has always said he'll take talent over experience (or salary), and that was backed up with this morning's roster moves. Pitchers Rick Porcello and Ryan Perry can now officially call themselves major leaguers, as both of them were named to the team. (Thanks to Billfer, who passed along the news via Twitter, and Peazgrl for breaking the story in a FanPost.)
Two other pitchers who were fighting for a job and made the cut were Eddie Bonine and Juan Rincon. Bonine should take that long relief role, while Rincon joins Perry in setting up Brandon Lyon and Fernando Rodney in the late innings. (Or will we have a closer-by-committee, with Rodney currently Leyland's favored choice to get the call in the ninth?)
With Porcello joining the starting staff, the other remaining spot in the rotation will go to Zach Miner. Miner keeps a seat warm for the injured Jeremy Bonderman. And once Dondo's shoulder heals up and he's ready to join the team, Miner will likely head back to relieving, pushing Bonine back to Triple-A Toledo. So Nate Robertson loses out, and ends up as the second left-hander in the bullpen. (That, in turn, sends Clay Rapada to the Mud Hens.) Scott Williamson was also assigned to minor league camp. (And as I've said, I hope he agrees to go to Toledo.)
How about on the position player side of the roster? Infielder Ryan Raburn and catcher Dane Sardinha were both optioned to Toledo, while Mike Hessman was told he'll be placed on waivers. If he clears waivers, Hessman says he'd like to return to Toledo. However, he'll also look for opportunities to play in Japan. (Raburn, meanwhile, could be on his way to the St. Louis Cardinals, if they can work out a deal with the Tigers.)
But that last bench spot still remains open, with Jeff Larish and Brent Clevlen left to duke it out. It seems like a foregone conclusion that Larish will get the nod, as he was already playing well enough to make the team, and Josh Anderson took the outfield spot that could've gone to Clevlen. Three more days of Thunderdome - two men enter, one man leaves - for those two.
So I think I know the answer, but will ask anyway. Are you happy with these moves? And if, in fact, the Tigers intend to rotate that closer's job among two or three pitchers, how do you feel about that? You guys already got a head start this morning, but take it away.
0 recs |
15 comments
|
Comments
Its A Joke....
…..That after the spring Rapada had he goes to AAA and Robertson ends up at the Big League Level….A JOKE!!!!…..My guess is that when Bondo comes back Robertson will be in AAA and BONINE will stay in long relief….I JUST CANT BELIEVE THAT ROBERTSON IS THE 2ND LEFTY OUT OF THE PEN AND NOT RAPADA!!!!! ……RIDICULUS!!!!
by BennieBladesFan on Apr 1, 2009 2:57 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Rodney Should Be The Closer....
…….Hes the only one, Besides Lyon, To do It,,,,,,,AND I BELIEVE IS READY TO BREAK OUT!!!
by BennieBladesFan on Apr 1, 2009 2:58 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
With a one-run lead
I’d have to agree with you. At this point Brandon Lyon is homer happy. We’d probably have a better chance chewing our finger nalils while Rodney does his thing and hope for his best.
by densogirl on Apr 1, 2009 8:51 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
i had the thought yesterday when I saw Ian post about Sheff being gone (on facebook), that if it had happened a day later, it would have been a fantastic, “Is this real, or is this an april fools joke??!”
Had to check and make sure this wasn’t a bunch of tomofoolery, too. Porcello will have his ups and down, but given the state of the pitching rotation, he deserves a regular turn at major league level.
by ahtrap on Apr 1, 2009 4:10 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I like the moves
Rapada is short relief, which they have plenty of, but need robertson for some mop up duties. Bonine pitched well enough to stay, and it gives more time for Dombrowski to fool someone into taking Robertson. I think after a terrible offeseason last year DD is finally making some fitting moves.
by nerdrock1985 on Apr 1, 2009 4:38 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
kids should stay
The pitching staff as a whole is in very bad shape right now. Even with these guys on the roster, there are way too many question marks. The closer spot is particularly troubling. But hopefully one or both of those guys can hold it down for a while. Maybe Perry will be lights out, mature, and be able to take over the role. Maybe Zumaya will come back completely healthy. Big ifs, along with lots of others. With so many, you have to keep the talent around and let them try to figure it out on the fly.
by cloud wall on Apr 1, 2009 5:10 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
James Skelton???
I just checked the Arizona sites… but no word yet about their plans for James Skelton. I’m holding out hope that he is squeezed out of Arizona’s 25 man roster and returned to Detroit. Then I can forgive DD for instead protecting the likes of Gary Sheffield, Mike Hessman, Eddie Bonine, etc and then selecting (and returning) Kyle Bloom from the Pirates.
by trross1200 on Apr 1, 2009 5:45 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Need more speed
Its a joke. I agree with you.Looks like the boss likes 6 run 5 inning Nate!I like the moves to get younger but still not enough speed in the lineup.
by Robertdogsworld on Apr 1, 2009 9:34 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I agree with you...
….but, its not like the Tigers have a bunch of speedy guys they decided to send down. They just don’t have many guys that have speed. Newcomer Josh Anderson does though, and I give Dombrowski credit for getting a guy who brings a dimension the current team lacked. Here are Anderson’s yearly stolen base totals in his pro career (granted, mostly spread across various minor leagues):
2004: 78
2005: 50
2006: 43
2007: 41
2008: 52
by ThaWalrus9 on Apr 1, 2009 9:56 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
As far as Porcello & Perry
Let’s be honest here. The 2009 Tigers have a lot of talent, but a lot of things need to break right for them to be contenders. Verlander has to bounce back, Bondo has to come back from injury, the bottom of the lineup needs to avoid being a black hole, etc. The pitching staff is shaky. I would rather the Tigers take their chances with a few high ceiling arms that might not be quite ready rather than vomiting in my hat every 5th day when Nate Robertson tries to beat other teams with his best Mark Redman impression. It might not work, but hell, last year was a pretty strong indication that Robertson and/or Willis DEFINITELY won’t work.
Give me the young guys, not the retreads.
by ThaWalrus9 on Apr 1, 2009 10:05 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Kevin Goldstein on RP:
" Rick Porcello, Tigers. While it hasn’t been made official yet, he remains the talk of Tigers camp after another stellar outing last Wednesday. Jeremy Bonderman’s arm and Dontrelle Willis’ head have created openings, and all signs point to the 2007 first-round pick beginning the year in the big-league rotation as a 20-year-old. He’s incredibly difficult to project; the fact that he led the Florida State League with a 2.66 ERA in his full-season debut is remarkable, but made even more so by the fact that the Tigers limited Porcello’s arsenal much of the season by forcing him to work more on throwing strikes and working efficiently as opposed to just blowing hitters away. The overall goal was to transform the best arm in the 2007 draft from a thrower into a pitcher, but the question remains whether 24 starts at High-A is enough of a lesson for him to be ready. His talent is unmistakable, his readiness is debatable."
by ThaWalrus9 on Apr 1, 2009 10:46 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
and Goldstein on Ryan Perry:
Perry has officially faced 65 batters as a professional, but with Joel Zumaya remaining firmly in the ‘broken’ file, we approach April with him still in camp as the favorite to begin the year in the big leagues. One of the fastest risers in last year’s draft, Perry really hasn’t missed a beat since last spring at Arizona, as he’s sat at 96-98 mph with an overpowering fastball while giving up just one run on eight hits over 11 2/3 innings this spring. To put him in the big leagues at this point is probably more out of the team absolute need than a reflection of his readiness, but scouts are saying that the quality stuff he’s showing should be enough for him to easily hold his own, and should help the stock of this year’s crop of college closers as teams look for some instant returns in the draft.
by ThaWalrus9 on Apr 1, 2009 10:51 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
porcello
looks like u of m qb David Cone
by dettigionswings'stons on Apr 1, 2009 11:16 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Miner
I hope he pitches as good as he has the last few games… Then maybe he’ll send Porcello to the minors O.o
by ZWC11 on Apr 2, 2009 2:08 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 
















