Morning Prowl: Mid-Season Grades, Clumsy Attacks on Bloggers, and a Call For Clete
The Tigers are now officially into the second half of the season, which means mid-season grades are being assigned throughout the Tigersosphere. First up is The Detroit Tigers Weblog, who looks at some numbers and projects them out over a full season. Billfer also has a handful of awards for some entertaining categories.
What does it look like when a cranky old sports columnist uses his forum to take a clumsy shot at bloggers, thus making his entire article look unfocused and perplexing? The Star-Tribune's Patrick Reusse provides just such an example, with a baffling swing (along with painfully forced joke) at Take 75 North's Matt Wallace over the Edwin Jackson-Matt Joyce trade.
I mean this seriously: I've read Reusse's column several times, and don't know what he's talking about. Matt criticized the Jackson-Joyce trade, so if the Twins had made a better deal than trading Matt Garza for Delmon Young, Minnesota would lead the AL Central right now? Trying to follow his logic will make you dizzy. Reusse's ham-fisted attempt at an insult made about as much sense as me ending this sentence by telling you I ordered a pizza with spinach and feta cheese on it last night. At least Reusse could've linked to Matt's post.
Here is Matt's response, though he graciously takes the high road by keeping the discussion about baseball (and if Reusse had done that, maybe his column would've been coherent), rather than engage in bloggers vs. traditional media mud-slinging.
Mack Avenue Tigers thinks it's time for Clete Thomas to return to Detroit. I agree that the Don Kelly experiment has probably run its course, and the two should switch places between Detroit and Toledo. (Though if Josh Anderson wasn't out of options, would he draw the short straw?)
Was Carlos Guillen really the Tigers' representative at last year's All-Star Game? That seems so easy to forget now.
Eye of the Tigers has some very sobering numbers about Detroit's record when they score three or fewer runs. You can add another loss to that record after last night's defeat to the Royals.
Sort of lost among the All-Star bids, campaigning for Brandon Inge, and Rick Porcello's skipped start was the news that Alfredo Figaro was put on the 15-day disabled list for a sprained wrist. Was that injury affecting him during his start in Houston?
Would the corner of Michigan and Trumbull be a good spot for a new hockey arena for the Red Wings? Terry Foster addresses the question in the Detroit News. I wonder if Corktown residents would really want another sports venue there.
Passing out some more traditional letter grades is DesigNate Robertson. Rogo's a fair grader, and I think I only disagree with one of his marks (the last one).
We're a few days late on this link, but The Spot Starters looks at who might play second base for the Tigers in 2010. And giving the job to an inside hire looks a lot better than the free-agent candidates that will be available (other than possibly keeping Placido Polanco on a short-term deal).
0 recs |
15 comments
|
Comments
I would love to see Clete
back in the lineup. Kelly hasn’t offered too much, not the way they hoped anyway. Josh, well he’s fast and got lucky last night. He hasn’t looked that great in the OF lately. It’s almost as mortifying as watching an aging Magglio out there. And Does anyone know how Larish has been doing sent they sent him back down?
Welcome to Detroit>>Where the weak are killed and eaten.
by Detroitchik on Jul 7, 2009 9:48 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
anderson can't hit
Disagree on the Anderson grade. He’s been one of the five worst hitters in baseball (with over 150 plate appearances) and hasn’t walked since May 22 (67 at bats). Speed is useless if a guy doesn’t get on base). Would like to see them send down Anderson and Kelly and bring back Thomas and Larish.
Anderson/Kelly: 196 at bats, 0 homers 9 walks
Thomas/Larish: 188 at bats, 8 homers, 28 walks
While they weren’t all stars or anything, at least Thomas and Larish contributed something. There’s a huge drop off with Kelly and Anderson, plus neither is as good as Thomas defensively and Larish is an above average first baseman.
by ddpg4 on Jul 7, 2009 12:04 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
"I think I only disagree with one of his marks (the last one)."
I agree with this ^
And especially this:
“Matt Treanor, F
0 for 13, out for the year. Thanks for coming. Your wife is hot.”
by Tagne13 on Jul 7, 2009 9:59 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
off topic
Mobile commenting enabled! I’m no longer a prisoner to company firewalls
http://www.fromthecopa.blogspot.com
by rock n rye on Jul 7, 2009 10:07 AM EDT via mobile reply actions 0 recs
I want to see Clete!
Send down Kelly (also I’d never send down Anderson, it’s too nice having his speed, look what we were able to do with it yesterday, despite losing).
by ZWC11 on Jul 7, 2009 12:40 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Kelly's Numbers Are Superior To Thomas's With The Hens
Guillen should be back in a couple of weeks. Why call up Thomas and turn around and send him down again when Guillen returns especially with the all star break coming up?
Kelly has only had 48 ABs (18 the past 2 weeks). Thomas was given 114 ABs to try and prove himself before being sent down. Kelly’s numbers at Toledo were superior to Thomas’s with the Hens. Let’s give Kelly another couple of weeks.
by 63 Tiger on Jul 7, 2009 4:00 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
so fast he's invisible
I think even Cabrera or Ordonez would have scored from first on Rayburn’s near triple, so hard to see where Anderson’s speed made a difference yesterday. In fact, the only way I’ve seen Anderson’s speed come into play this year is when he’s so fast to swing at the pitcher’s first or second pitch and hits his usual weak grounder to short, he’s so quick to get to the dugout that people don’t notice he’s in the game. That’s the only explanation I can see for why a guy who’s played in 69 games, batted 148 times and has zero homers, 3 doubles, and only 6 walks is still on the team. If Mags could run fast while he tapped and popped out, maybe people wouldn’t notice that he wasn’t hitting either (of course his OPS is 85 points higher than Anderson’s). If fans are so enthralled with speed, they should lobby the Tigers to sign Tyson Gay. But personally, I would like to see them get some baseball players who can hit, so they can score some more runs.
by ddpg4 on Jul 7, 2009 5:47 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Wilkin Ramirez
Wilkin has 24 steals in AAA and some pop as we saw in his one game up. Send Mr Anderson down, even at the risk of losing him, and call up Wilkin.
With Guillen maybe coming back soon I think you substitute Guillen and Ramirez for Anderson and Kelly.
by ThaWalrus9 on Jul 7, 2009 2:20 PM EDT via mobile reply actions 0 recs
no no no you got it all wrong
it’s “CUT RODNEY”
by MackAveKurt on Jul 7, 2009 4:02 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
+1
Welcome to Detroit>>Where the weak are killed and eaten.
by Detroitchik on Jul 8, 2009 2:52 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Very Sobering Numbers
Yes, Detroit is now 9-28 in games where they score 3 or fewer (and what’s with the correct grammar? why not “3 or less” like everyone else writes?). But I don’t particularly feel like being any more sober than I am, so I’ll point out that their 9-28 is also BEST in their division.
And while we are on the high side for number of games with 3 or fewer, because we win more of them we still have fewer total losses with 3 or less than anyone:
3 runs or fewer:
DET 9-28 .243
KCR 9-33 .214
MIN 7-29 .194
CHW 4-29 .121
CLE 2-30 .063
(Now Cleveland’s record, THAT is sobering…ouch).
If you score 0-2 you’ll probably lose; 6+ you’ll win. If you have a more or less normal number of games in those categories, it all comes down to what you do in the 3-5 run games.
by ColemanOld on Jul 8, 2009 4:25 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 














