Baseball Hall of Fame: Andre Dawson (and his .323 OBP) inducted. Trammell, Morris get the shaft
I've always considered the majority of members of the Baseball Writers Association of America to be an insulated, pompous, grudge holding group of ink-stained wretches, for several reasons...but mostly due to their odd reasoning as to the who, when, how and why in regard to Baseball Hall of Fame voting.
Speaking of which...
The results of the Baseball Hall of Fame balloting have been released, and once again, Alan Trammell and Jack Morris get the cold shoulder from the clueless BBWAA.
In one of the tightest elections ever, Andre Dawson was the only player elected by the Baseball Writers Association of America to the Baseball Hall of Fame.
Dawson received 77.9 percent of the vote, just above the 75 percent needed for enshrinement. Bert Blyleven got 74.2 percent, missing election by just five votes. Roberto Alomar, widely expected to be a shoo-in, finished third with 73.7 percent. Jack Morris and Barry Larkin were the only other players to top 50 percent.
Alomar and Blyleven (and a case for Tim Raines can be made as well) not getting into Cooperstown are more egregious slights than Trammell continuing to get next to no support. At the very least, their just missing the hall this time around almost ensures they'll be voted in before they fall off the ballot.
There were a pair of Veteran's Committee sections as well. Manager Whitey Herzog, winner of 3 NL pennants and 1 World Series with the St. Louis Cardinals, and long-time NL umpire Doug Harvey were chosen to join Dawson in the hall.
Via BBWAA.com, the official vote totals are after the jump.

Trammell gets a lousy 22.4% of the vote, while Barry Larkin, who had a career very similar to Trammell's, gets 51.6%? I'd really like to hear the ink-stained wretches explain that one. Seriously, I'd like an explanation.
If Larkin gets in the hall (as it ultimately looks as he will, considering his strong performance in his first appearance on the ballot) before Trammell...I'll write a strongly worded blog post ripping the BBWAA to shreds. (Trust me, I'd like to do more...)
It'll be a huge injustice, and expose the membership of the BBWAA for what they are...a group in which the majority are writing in a dying medium, and like to throw around what little influence they have left.
As for Jack Morris, I'm not sure he can ever do much better in the voting than he is currently.He seems to be a polarizing figure with the voters. Despite all his accomplishments, it's Morris' career 3.90 ERA, more than anything else, keeping him out of the hall.
I've pretty much accepted it's going to be up to the Veteran's Committee to correct the voting wrongs when it comes to the 80's era Detroit Tigers.
And that's a damn shame.
32 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Darn
Beat me narrowly… oh well.
President, Vice President and Secretary of the Casey Crosby Fanclub.
Got the numbers
539 ballots, five blanks, Andre Dawson 420 (77.9%), Bert Blyleven 400 (74.2%), Roberto Alomar 397 (73.7%), Jack Morris 282 (52.3%), Barry Larkin 278 (51.6%), Lee Smith 255 (47.3%), Edgar Martinez 195 (36.2%), Tim Raines 164 (30.4%), Mark McGwire 128 (23.7%), Alan Trammell 121 (22.4%), Fred McGriff 116 (21.5%), Don Mattingly 87 (16.1%), Dave Parker 82 (15.2%), Dale Murphy 63 (11.7%), Harold Baines 33 (6.1%), Andres Galarraga 22 (4.1%), Robin Ventura 7 (1.3%), Ellis Burks 2 (0.4%), Eric Karros 2 (0.4%), Kevin Appier 1 (0.2%), Pat Hentgen 1 (0.2%), David Segui 1 (0.2%), Mike Jackson 0, Ray Lankford 0, Shane Reynolds 0, Todd Zeile 0.
President, Vice President and Secretary of the Casey Crosby Fanclub.
I'm shocked
that the Shane Reynolds candidacy fell so flat.
Blyleven and Alomar are in next year, so no point crying over what will eventually be spilled milk. Disappointing to see Trammell’s support seeming to hit a plateau. Larkin got off to a nice start, so you’d think he’ll be in sooner or later. I think there’s too much anti-Morris sentiment (deserved) for him to ever get to 75%. Raines at 30% is the worst thing I see about this year’s ballot. Well, and the fact that Ellis Burks and David Segui got votes…
Trammell
I’m hoping that the stathead community focuses on his campaign after getting Blyleven into the Hall (which damn well better happen).
President, Vice President and Secretary of the Casey Crosby Fanclub.
What's the VC procedure?
Is it possible Whitaker can get in the same year as Tram if one is still on the ballot?
President, Vice President and Secretary of the Casey Crosby Fanclub.
Whitaker is out - period
Lou Whitaker did not recieve the required 5% of the vote in his first ballot and therefore cannot even be considered by the Veterans Committee. I believe the rules were changed a few years ago and there are pretty strict guidelines as to who that committee can consider and if a player did not make that cut the first year he is out for good.
It’s too bad because I believe a side by side comparison to second basemen of his era would put Whittaker pretty high on the list the very best. Roberto Alomar was the best and will get in next year but after that I cannot think of many better second sackers of the 80’s than Lou Whittaker.
The Hall of Fame needs to look at changing rules, voting procedures, and credentials. Whittaker got overlooked by writers but probably would have recieved the votes of his peers and or broadcasters.
I don't really care who is in or out to be honest
but I find it pretty stupid that writers have more say than people who played the friggen game.
All your favorite Tigers blog are belong to me.
Bless You Boys.com -- MackAvenueTigers.com
by Kurt Mensching on Jan 7, 2010 11:14 AM EST up reply actions
and the fact that David Segui received a vote
Doesn’t speak too well for the sanity of some of these writers
by rock n rye on Jan 7, 2010 11:19 AM EST via mobile up reply actions
That's such garbage
Whitaker was one of the best 2B of all time.
President, Vice President and Secretary of the Casey Crosby Fanclub.
maybe not?
I found this on Wiki (I know, consider the source), but according to this, the 2007 rules changes did not affect Whitaker’s potential candidacy. The 2003 rules revisions stated that “Every player with 10 or more years of major-league experience who has not been active in the previous 20 years, and is not on Major League Baseball’s ineligible list, is eligible for Veterans Committee consideration. In the past, players who did not receive a certain percentage of the votes on a BBWAA ballot were permanently ineligible for Hall of Fame consideration.” As far as I can tell, the 2007 changes did not apply to the eligibility requirements. So it appears that Whitaker would become eligible for the 2015 VC ballot.
?
“deserved” anti-Morris sentiment? Is it his ERA versus his other accomplishments? Or do they truly think he wasn’t one of baseball’s best for nearly a decade? If the Hall is supposed to represent the games greatest players, then he’s in. If its “who was a really good player and nice to the media” contest, then sure, scratch him off.
The Trammell “controversy” grows more and more ludicrous as you compare him to Smith and Larkin of his era, who are or will be in. The voters are holding the “lack of” an MVP against him…the same voters who screwed him in ’87.
Going beyond the Tiger slights, the fact that Don Mattingly gets almost no consideration (again, mainly due to “career stats”), and Gary Sheffield WILL get major consideration, tells me all I need to know about the Hypocritical of Fame.
The world's greatest wiffle ball tournament! TheFatty.com
McGwire 23,7
Too many people loves steroids.
Morris – 52.3% – maybe he’ll be elect in next 2-3 years.
Also
I’ve always considered the majority of members of the Baseball Writers Association of America to be an insulated, pompous, grudge holding group of ink-stained wretches, for several reasons…
Best thing I’ve read all day.
President, Vice President and Secretary of the Casey Crosby Fanclub.
by David Tokarz on Jan 6, 2010 3:16 PM EST reply actions 3 recs
Thanks!
Actually, I held back a little, as it is my first post as an official member of the BYB editorial team.
I could have added wannabe exclusionary elitists who are stuck in the 20th century, have a definite big market bias and press box meal moochers as well!
I'm owner/editor of The Wayne Fontes Experience and a deputy editor at Bless You Boys.
done !
All your favorite Tigers blog are belong to me.
Bless You Boys.com -- MackAvenueTigers.com
by Kurt Mensching on Jan 7, 2010 6:30 PM EST up reply actions
I don't understand how Shane Reynolds and Eric Karros were even on this ballot...
Reynolds had an ERA above 4.00, and barely a winning record…
A lifelong Tigers fan
It's just an honor for them
I’m not particularly offended by that- it’s a nice little nod.
President, Vice President and Secretary of the Casey Crosby Fanclub.
Thank you…My step-daughter did it for me.
by markov94 on Jan 6, 2010 10:51 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
McGwire was a hell of a hitter
Granted, Tram is one of the best SS ever, but McGwire is a hell of a hitter…
President, Vice President and Secretary of the Casey Crosby Fanclub.
by David Tokarz on Jan 7, 2010 12:31 AM EST up reply actions
Inclusion on the HoF Ballot
Someone asked why average players were even on the HoF Ballot. The rules are if you played during 10 Championship Seasons (the regular season) you are eligible to be on the HoF Ballot 5 years after your last season of play. That is how the average players like Shane Reynolds, Todd Zeile, and Ellis Burke were on the ballot.
Hurts to play in fly-over country.
If Trammell, Morris and Blyleven had played on the east or west coast, they’d be in.
Heard a stupid reason not to vote for Blyleven the other day. No world series title. He pitched for Cleveland for cripes sake!

by 


















