Report: Armando Galarraga traded to Diamondbacks
After Dombrowski mentioned at TigerFest that he thinks he'll soon have a trade in place for Galarraga, I figured something would come up today. It's been six days since he was designated for assignment, so they're going to have to figure something out pretty quick - they have ten days total to do so.
Jon Heyman tweets that the Diamondbacks are his likely destination. No other info yet, but we'll update this post as we find out more.
UPDATE: More sources are saying it could be done today and would involve RHP Kevin Eichhorn and possibly another player.
UPDATE #2: The front office tweeted that the deal is done. LHP Ryan Robowski is the other player the Tigers acquire.
41 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Farewell Mando
It was an up and down stay here in Detroit, but for one night you were perfect in the eyes of every Tigers fan
via MLBTR
“The teams are likely to complete a trade today, according to MLB.com’s Steve Gilbert. Eichhorn and another player would got to Detroit and the D’Backs would take on most of Galarraga’s $2.3MM salary.”
If the Tigers actually have to take on salary
Then I guess the leaguewide opinion of Galarraga is a lot lower than I’d anticipated.
by ozymandius1024 on Jan 24, 2011 12:42 PM EST reply actions
I doubt they take on much salary
If they put him on waivers and he’s claimed, they actually receive a waiver fee
If he clears waivers and they release him, they owe just under $ 385K
So it makes no sense to pay more salary than that, unless they’re basically buying the players that they get back in the deal. It’s not just that Armando doesn’t have a lot of value as a back of the rotation pitcher, of which there are several options on the free agent market worth a gamble, but that he comes with a $ 2.3MM salary, and he’s maybe not worth much added value above that in the eyes of other clubs. Of course, they could cut their losses and release him too, but that’s obviously not the plan when they trade for him.
If you survived 2003, you can get through this!
From the Arizona Republic
A source told The Republic that a deal isn’t expected to occur until sometime this week, which is when Dombrowski said he expected a deal to be finalized. The Diamondbacks also appear to be in a position to pay Galarraga’s entire salary.
DD may as well wait and see what’s the best bid he can get, unless there is only one potential suitor and he doesn’t want to lose them.
If you survived 2003, you can get through this!
I would have been happy
With just getting Eichhorn, add in another player and we are getting a very nice deal for Mando, even if the other player is just an organizational body.
Robowski
22 yrs old, lefty pitcher. A 16th round pick in the 2009 draft. Posted a 5.17 ERA and 1.57 WHIP at the Hi A level last year. I’m sure someone will dig up a scouting report on him.
If you survived 2003, you can get through this!
Robowski
Numbers here. Outdated scouting report here.
LOOGY at best, org arm at worst.
Deputy Editor, Bless You Boys
Free Scott Sizemore!
by David Tokarz on Jan 24, 2011 4:09 PM EST up reply actions
Mark Anderson on Twitter
Deputy Editor, Bless You Boys
Free Scott Sizemore!
by David Tokarz on Jan 24, 2011 4:18 PM EST up reply actions
Isn't Robowski . . .
. . . the guy who runs DesignateRobertson? Or am I more confused than ususal?
Dbacks the winner by a far margin
DD gave away depth for two pitchers that struggle a A ball. Beside don’t we have abundance of pitchers at ABall. These type of pitchers can be pick up in the later rounds of this year draft. This is a joke just like the 08 draft was referring to drafting so many relievers when they are abundance in free agency. .
He just transitioned to starting this year as well
I’m not saying the kid will ever make the big leagues, but he’s only 20 so I’m not going to dog him too hard yet.
This could very easily be a non-factor like the Dontrelle Willis deal, but the Tigers aren’t eating salary here, and they’ll have a couple million more if they need to make a deadline deal this season. I’m not going to lose any sleep about it.
by ozymandius1024 on Jan 24, 2011 4:48 PM EST up reply actions
Tigers have lots of them
They needed depth then they need more pitching prospects.
Depth is having more arms in the system.
Instead you want things that teams were not going to give up for Armando.
Sometimes I can put words together but other times they fall apart... like Greg Oden.
What do you think teams were going to trade for Galarraga?
No one in the league thinks he’s very good, and with good reason. Pitchers who post career K/BB ratios of 1.62 are pretty easy to find.
Exactly, so why trade him
He was our Insurance Policy. Galarrage had lower WHIP than Porcello and Coke and pitch more innings than Penny. Mr I is full of money. too.
Maybe he didn't want to be a long reliever until someone went down/sucked?
It’s not a given that the Tigers just wanted to unload the guy. Even if they did just want to unload him, Armando Galarraga isn’t a guy you worry about not being on your baseball team.
by ozymandius1024 on Jan 24, 2011 6:00 PM EST up reply actions
Where was he gonna pitch?
You’re completely forgetting about the implications on the roster. He was out of options, so he couldn’t go to AAA. If he went to the bullpen and pitched in a regular role, he would have been unable to start once the need arised. If he went to the bullpen and sat there ready to pitch a full game, he would have wasted a roster spot. Why should the Tigers spend so much effort accommodating someone who sucks?
Why would he be unable to start if the need arised.
He has been a starter since the Tigers got him.
by swish330 on Jan 25, 2011 10:46 AM EST up reply actions 1 recs
you cant go from pitching 2 innings every other day
to pitching 5-6 innings effectively every fifth day. If he’s a middle reliever, he’ll be useless as a full time starter if needed in the middle of the season
"I'm a simple man. I like pretty, dark-haired women and breakfast food" - Ron Swanson
Honestly are you sure about that.
It might take him a few starts to get up to speed,but these are athletes who are in the prime of there careers.Do you really think they can only pitch two innings at the age of 29.
And if we're waiting on a few starts to get him "up to speed"
after we’ve already given up on one of our rotation men, we’re doomed already.
Would have preferred a positional player.
But I guess you can’t ask for too much for a fifth starter. Eichhorn has posted good strikeout rates and looks to have good control, but you can’t get too excited over a guy who hasn’t made it out of rookie ball in three years. Robowski looks like filler.
The Tigers didn't get anything to get excited about in this trade.
This was a dumb move from the beginning for the Tigers,Gallarraga was insurance for the rotation and could of pitched long relief.They should of held on to him thru spring training to see that we didn’t need another starter.And one of the other clubs might of had an injury and offered more for him.When everyone know you have to trade someone you can’t expect to get much in return.This is one of DD’s worst trades.
There's more to this one than meets the public eye
Armando would have been hanging around, literally waiting for an accident to happen, figuratively breathing down Phil Coke’s neck as he tried to make the transition to the rotation. I don’t like trading away starting pitching for basically nothing, but I’d bet a benjamin against a donut that they just didn’t feel that Armando would take well to a relief role, and he didn’t fit into their long term plans with all the young guns that have plenty of upside on the way up.
As for his market value, DD had several days to field calls, and quite a while prior to the announcement that Galarraga would be DFA’ed. I’d have kept him for depth, but then I don’t have to deal with the personalities in Lakeland- the competition that may not be as healthy as we’d all like to think it would be. As much as I don’t like the deal, it’s not likely to kill us. I do think that Armando is a good bit better than whomever they have right now to fill a rotation spot should the need arise. We now have to hope that someone (that’s you, Andy Oliver) develops quickly, before there is a need in the rotation. That’s my .02
If you survived 2003, you can get through this!
Since they have traded Gallarraga,now we need a back-up plan.
I think they should go out and sign Chad Durbin as a long reliever and back-up starter.Every team in MLB last year used at least 7 starters during the course of the 2010 season.The Tigers only have 5 starters right now and thats counting on Cokes transition to starter.We shouldn’t go in to this season counting on Oliver or Turner to start,they may not be ready yet.
Good Deal, dumped the salary, got a couple players
AG had ok stuff, nothing to write home about. He also slowed down the game hurting the def. Am glad Oliver, Villereal, and Furbush will get a shot as the 6th, 7th and 8th. All 3 have better stuff than AG and say what you want about experience, but 4-9 is an experience I don’t wanna experience again. Durbin would be a good pickup, he is Ok with long relief, and has had a nice run with Philly.
Agree with you and that Benjamin, Tiger. Something didn’t add up with AG. Despite the class of the no-hitter, the camera’s caught an angry guy at times. He also got shipped out of sping training to fast last season, something was up. Guess we will never know, good luck AG.
"Always 1984"
by Hack Johnson on Jan 24, 2011 7:36 PM EST up reply actions
I can't help but think Furbush and Oliver
can put up the same production as Galaraga with a lot better upside
With the lack of starters on the team now.
We might just find out if Oliver,Turner and Furbish are ready.And if so i don’t see anyway of the Tigers beating the White Soxs and Twins.If you go over each teams roster player by player the Tigers will need to have the starters Verlander,Scherzer,Penny,Porcello and Coke healthy and pitching well to win the division.They need to bring in a safety valve like Chad Durbin who can be a relief pitcher and a starter if need be.But DD said they won’t do anything else intill pitchers and catchers report.
Chicago and Minnesota had No. 6 starters...
Chicago had Buehrle, Danks, Floyd, Peavy, and Freddy Garcia, with Daniel Hudson and Chris Sale in the minors. Then, they traded Hudson for Edwin Jackson.
Hudson would be comparable to Andy Oliver. Higher ceiling, but still struggled when he got a few starts in Chicago, then thrived in Arizona. Sale looks like a solid pitcher, and they have six counting him to start this season.
The Twinkies keep pulling pitchers outta nowhere. They had Liriano, Pavano, Baker, Slowey, Blackburn, and Deunsing. They had Manship and Perkins, who’ve also had a little starting experience in the majors, but didn’t need them for more than a spot start.
The Tigers now have Andy Oliver, who projects to be a No. 3 or 4 starter when he gets command of his repertoire, but he showed last year that he’s clearly not ready. If the need arose, the Tigers would be calling him up prematurely. The alternative would be a lower grade minor leaguer that’s not ready, such as Furbush, Below, or Villarreal, or go off the roster and call up Enrique Gonzalez. If Oliver is ready, we’re all set. If not, we could damage him and I don’t want to see that. If it’s just a spot start, they may go to Brad Thomas or whomever’s turn it is in Toledo on that day.
If you survived 2003, you can get through this!
The twins always seem to pull someone out...
For Chicago I wouldn’t call Sale a #6 since he is a reliever, and a short reliever at that (although his numbers do look like he is going to be a pretty good set-up man soon). I wouldn’t call Freddy Garcia at this stage to much of an upgrade out of anyone that Tigers might call up for a spot start or two.
I really like Deunsing and think he is going to be pretty decent in whatever roll they finally put him in. Blackburn….not that good. Slowey, decent but not great, Solid 4/5. As for Manship he seems to be similar to Oliver. Has potential but isn’t ready for the majors yet. Perkins looks like he is going to be a career middle/long relief guy that will get occasional starts.
I just don’t see this as being so much better off than the Tigers in terms of depth, the only difference is that they have a little more major league experience. The talent seems about equal though.
I get tired of people saying that Oliver doesn’t look ready based on what he did a month and a half before the season ended… Do you not think he would have worked on what he was doing wrong when he went back to the minors? Or even during the off-season? Yes, he showed that he wasn’t ready when they called him up, that has nothing to do with right now though. He went from AA to the majors, showed he needed some work, went to AAA and pitched pretty darn well there. He is still walking too many, but again I am sure he has been working on it. Do I think he is ready right now? No, but I think he is a lot closer now then he was when they used him last year. He might even be ready by the all-star break, or he might need another 3 years. To say he is clearly not ready now though is not correct.
Sale is a starter
and if Peavy is not healthy or they trade Edwin, he WILL be in the rotation. If they have six healthy starters on opening day, he’ll go to the pen because he’s too good to leave in the minors. Kenny Williams has said that he just wants to commit to him one way or the other by opening day, rather than start him in the pen and move him over if needed. They’ve even talked about him closing, which is surprising since they have Matt Thornton there. But Sale is definitely a starter if they need him.
The Twinkies are going to camp with six starters also, and they’ll see who gets beaten out of a job. Perkins stock dropped big time last year, and Manship can’t seem to crack the rotation, but they still have six others.
Oliver needs to command all his pitches with much more consistency, and do it for a period of time before I’d call him up. However, he is now definitely No. six on the Tigers, ready or not. I believe they would call him up unless he’s stinking it up in Toledo should the need arise, and I don’t like the call up for the wrong reasons. It should be all about him and not about desperation. I hasten to add that when he does command his full repertoire, I’d put him ahead of Bondo, AG, Penny, Coke, and knocking on Porcello’s door (depending on what Ricky does). Since Andy hasn’t settled in with his command for the required (in my book) period of time, he’s clearly not ready. He could be ready very quickly, or never. There’s a graveyard- gotta be somewhere around Monroe or Flat Rock, full of pitchers that got lost between Toledo and Detroit. Rumor has it they’re buried on Zug Island, but that’s not confirmed.
If you survived 2003, you can get through this!
I just looked at the raw numbers on Sale
Since he has been playing professional ball he has never started a game. It looks like he averages about 1 inning per outing.
Read a story or two on him, and honestly his destiny is up in the air. Seems as though he is an either or at this point and all the Sox know is that he has talent… He also appears to have some problems with his delivery that might make him a bad long term choice as a starter.
He is the guy most likely to start for Peavy and I guess that would make him a #6 starter, however I don’t really count him as any better depth then Oliver.
I guess the point I was trying to make is that; honestly our depth is no worse than either of the other two contenders in the division. Technically, Oliver (at this point) is our #6. If you or I think that he is ready for it or not is moot, I am sure there are people in Chi-town that think Sale needs another year in the minors as well (he seems to have the same control issues as Oliver). Would I like out depth to be better? Sure, I think every fan wants their starting pitching depth to be better. Are we in a horrible position? I don’t think so.
It's more a case of, if we can add depth, and its not very costly, then why not do it?
No question that Oliver would be the first man up if there was a vacancy, ready or not. I believe that Andy has enough of an upside that they should let him progress at his own pace. He could be ready soon or never, but let him work on what he needs to work on until then.
I think Chicago screwed up trading Daniel Hudson.
If you survived 2003, you can get through this!

by 
























