What would you do with today's lineup?
Tigers manager Jim Leyland has a bit of a conundrum. He set his lineup to face a left-handed pitcher on Friday night. The game began, and lasted an inning and a half before being suspended. Now, the Yankees will send right-hander Ivan Nova to the mound. Since the game continues as if there was simply a 23 hour rain delay, Leyland is stuck with his lineup.
Sure, he can make substitutions. But they are substitutions. So each one shortens his bench and threatens to hamstring him later in the game.
So what do you do in Leyland's shoes? (Besides: Light a smoke. Find something to eat. Put your feet up on the desk and spray the reporters with food crumbs.)
The first thing is, remain calm. Leyland seems to be doing that.
The second thing -- which Leyland probably won't do -- is to check the splits. If you do, you'll find that Nova does not decimate right-handed batters. He actually has a reverse split during his major league career, so he's better against left-handers.
Maybe you don't want to change anything at all. Maybe you make a minor change or two. Just remember, the more moves you make early the less chess match you can play later. (And the more the fear of an untimely injury comes up.)
Honestly, I might make one change. I might not.
Doug Fister is a groundball pitcher. Keeping Brandon Inge in at third to help prevent runs seems like a pretty good idea to me. So I'm going to hold off on Wilson Betemit, to be honest.
However I might insert Ramon Santiago, a switch hitter, in at second base to further bolster the infield defense. If I'm feeling particularly randy, I move Raburn into the outfield so Santiago bats in the two-hole in place of Magglio Ordonez.
That's an interesting one to debate. First, it improves infield defense like I want. Second, Ordonez has hit well in the past month, but hasn't hit right-handers well in 2011. Raburn has hit like his butt is on fire for the past month, but also has some split problems against righties. Raburn leads Ordonez in both splits. (Again, I refer you back to Nova's splits and question how much of an impact this might actually be.) At least keeping Raburn in the game means that if Santiago or Jhonny Peralta suffered an injury, you'd still have a second baseman available. Taking Raburn out of the game means that you'd probably have to ask Don Kelly to do something he hasn't done in awhile: play the middle infield. But ultimately, we don't want to make too big a deal out of that point.
You could, of course, insert left-handed outfielder Andy Dirks in place of Ordonez as well. Not the worst idea either. He does have reverse splits too, but small sample size and all that like with Nova. Sill I don't mind keeping him on the bench at the start of the game either.
So there's all sorts of ideas out there. Which ones do ou prefer?
25 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Moving Rayburn to Outfield and Santiago to 2nd base sounds good.
Does anyone think the media is making a big deal of how CC was in a groove and JV looked rattled. For crying out loud CC was throwing in a freaking monsoon. It looked like a Tropical rain forest out there in the second.Tigers batters could not see a thing. They are calling it a tragedy for Yankees. Why the hell did the MLB start these games in the first place?
yeah we've seen verlander have a bit of a rough start and then get 12 or 15 batters in a row out
I mean they are the Yankees so it’s not THAT easy. But he isn’t a nobody either.
by Kurt Mensching on Oct 1, 2011 1:51 PM EDT up reply actions
Either one of them could have given up nothing or 5 runs
pretty stupid comments in general, they are both good pitchers, either one of them could have put up 0’s the rest of the game or given up 5 runs the next inning. Its baseball you can look great for 5 innings and then have a bloop, make a couple bad pithes and give up a croocked number and aces can get in the groove pretty easy so one mediocre inning doesn’t mean much. Verlander didn’t look great but Jeter struck out and he’s the one who scored. It probably helps us more if CC can’t pitch in 2 games but there was no advantage in the game yesterday either way.
I agree with this (of course)
you gain one lefty bat without losing anyone by Victor switching over. Santiago would be a second and he’d bat in the 2 slot for Magglio. Raburn goes to the OF and he made the last out. With Fister on the mound, Inge and Santiago in the infield strengthens the defense.
Nova features a nasty two seamer. If they can lay off that pitch and make him bring it up in the zone, he can be hit.
I don't care what the Chinese say, 2011 is the Year of the Tiger!
Probably going to get rained out again
would keep same lineup if it looks like a bunch of delays because then CC would be back on sunday, also would’t start fister, probably porcello if over 50% chance of more rain outs.
CC will not be back Sunday, the Yankees said today
by Kurt Mensching on Oct 1, 2011 1:52 PM EDT up reply actions
Yeah I heard but I'm not buying it
No way he won’t pitch tomorrow if it is still Game1 or they lose, they want him to start 2 games in the series. I heard leyland say a lot of things too, and then do the opposite, talk is cheap.
Ken Rosenthal reported that CC would lobby to get in Sunday
but he followed up with Girardi saying that wasn’t going to happen. AJ should be pitching game 4.
I don't care what the Chinese say, 2011 is the Year of the Tiger!
I hope not. Because that means this thing is still go which I think it will. I think it might go 5 Tigers are only a slightly better team than the Yankees. Either way so far it’s a great series. I would feel better if the Yankees could win with Garcia Sunday. Tigers are tough though. We learned that in ’06. We Yankees have good memories. May the best team win.
by bleedingyankeeblue on Oct 2, 2011 1:29 AM EDT up reply actions
Tonight's Pitching
I would not even think about warming up Nova if it looks like rain. If you get an hour or so delay , you would then lose him too. You are already in the third with a deep, rested pen. I would pitch Hughes or AJ and see how far they can go. Nova on sunday, Garcia and CC in Detroit.
Me too
Whenever Mike Ditka boards an aircraft, it changes its call sign to Bear Force One.
by Lester A. Wiltfong Jr. on Oct 1, 2011 3:47 PM EDT via iPhone app up reply actions
Strange that Nova has that kind of split
I still like to see better defense behind Fisher with Santiago at 2B and Raburn in right. With Dirks coming off the bench to pinch hit and then take over RF. Inge at 3B is okay, maybe he get that fastball down the middle and crack one.
Ramon Santiago In, Raburn Out of Game, Ordonez Stays In The Game
The rest stay in the game.
Dirks in for defense latter in the game.
I can buy this.
Remember, Raburn just batted. If we’re keeping him in the game for his bat (which I would assume is the only reason you ever have Raburn in a game), then we either A.) won’t see his bat for three more innings or B.) will see it sooner because we’re up a few runs.
Maggs has been hitting and fielding about as well as Raburn and I like his veteran-ness in the game. Keep him.
The other sports are just sports. Baseball is a love. ~Bryant Gumbel, 1981
Yeah, and I have a feeling that Magglio, who is up sooner than Raburn's slot, has a better shot to get a hit off Nova's two seam sinker
I don't care what the Chinese say, 2011 is the Year of the Tiger!
i concur with all this
maggs seems to hit pretty well in the playoffs if i remember right :)
also, he is who i want hitting in the pressure of yankee stadium. not raburn.
by situationalbuntingapologist on Oct 1, 2011 6:11 PM EDT up reply actions
I think he will probably leave the line-up as is
I think he should do what you suggested.
In the grand scheme though I think it won’t make much of a difference.
Lefties do hit Rivera and Wade better than righties, Logan split are close to equal
So it is not a bad idea to keep Betemit, Dirks or Kelly to pinch hit for Raburn, Maggs and Inge against Riveria and Wade if we are behind.
the worst part of this whole delay
now not only do i have to deal with huskies and sounders fans at the bar today, but seahawks fans tomorrow.
as for the lineup, i would let it ride for an inning or two and see what happens
Leyland doesn't have to change a thing
We probably got the best 9 on the field already. Raburn, Ordonez, and Inge have all been playing exceptionally well.
Ordonez had a .419 batting average and 1.003 OPS in September, that goes along with his current 18 game hitting streak.
Inge had a .324 AVG and .899 OPS in Sept.
Raburn had .383 AVG and 1.155 in Sept.
I wouldn't buy into Inge too much.
He averaged about 1AB per game in September…34 total. He had two 3 for 5 games in the first half of the month which are mostly responsible for his stats.
On the flip side, Inge hasn’t had a base hit since 9/18 and has only one base hit since 9/12. That’s one hit in nearly three weeks.
I’d leave him in the game for the defense, but I can’t justify his bat with stats.
The other sports are just sports. Baseball is a love. ~Bryant Gumbel, 1981
true, especially against a tough RHP with a nasty sinker like Nova
but I can justify his non-Betemit glove with Fister on the mound
I don't care what the Chinese say, 2011 is the Year of the Tiger!
Looking for positives
Not negatives. That is all.

by 
























