Shocking claim: Tigers have the relievers they need (probably).

As we enter a tryptophan-fueled holiday lull in the offseason, I thought I would poke a stick into the hive of discontent that surrounds the Tigers' bullpen. My aneurysm-inducing argument is that we already have the relievers we need - we just don't know who they are yet. Bullpens are largely a game of chance - they can go from disorder to elite performance and back again over the course of a season. Although I concede that the Tigers' relief corps could certainly be improved, my central claim is that we have enough lottery tickets to expect a reasonable level of performance in 2014.

My simplistic way of thinking about the bullpen is this: however you use them, you need at least 3 "plus" relievers - guys with ERA's typically below 3.50 - and at least 1 ought to be a southpaw. Beyond that, you'd like another 4 relievers who are at least "OK", with ERA's in roughly the 3.50 to 4.00 range. Splitting innings between pitchers like these, you could easily end up close to the league average bullpen ERA of ~3.50. Last year the Tigers' bullpen ERA was a subpar 4.01, including a hefty dose of early season disarray.

The problem that many of us see when looking at Detroit's tentative 2014 bullpen is that there are very few pitchers outside of Joe Nathan who seem like locks for the "Plus" or even the "OK" categories. Yet it seems like there may be a large number of pitchers (maybe more than in past years) who could potentially perform well for the Tigers. So I decided to tackle this issue with a small dose of solid statistics and a hefty heaping of subjectively conjuring numbers. Sound like fun? It actually sort of was.

For each reliever on the Tigers' 40 man roster (and a few off it), I gave my best guess at the probability that they would be at least "OK", and the chance that they would fall in my "Plus" category. Add them up and you have the expected number of righty and lefty relievers in each category, based on my intuitive say-so. I focused my predictions more based on the end of the season than the beginning (with playoffs in mind), allowing prospects some time to develop, and here's what I got:

Pitcher Chance of OK Chance of Plus
Al Alburquerque 65% 35%
Joba Chamberlain 35% 15%
Melvin Mercedes 25% 10%
Justin Miller 10% 2.5%
Joe Nathan 90% 85%
Jose Ortega 35% 5%
Luke Putkonen 60% 25%
Evan Reed 30% 5%
Bruce Rondon 80% 60%
Jose Valdez 10% 2.5%
Non-roster righty 60% 15%
Righty Subtotal: 5.00 2.60
Jose Alvarez 30% 10%
Phil Coke 40% 15%
Casey Crosby 10% 2.5%
Ian Krol 70% 35%
Kyle Lobstein 25% 7.5%
Non-roster lefty 80% 25%
Lefty Subtotal: 2.55 0.95

Basically, I predict that the Tigers will have 2 or 3 "Plus" righties and 1 "Plus" lefty. They would have another 2 or 3 "OK" righties and another 1 or 2 "OK" lefties". One thing that should catch your eye is the "non-roster" lines having relatively substantial numbers. Although there's no single non-roster player that I'm wildly optimistic about, in the aggregate these groups could potentially add an "OK" contributor each to the righty and lefty side. Here's where those numbers actually came from:

Non-roster righties:
Luis Marte 25% 5%
Jhan Martinez 10% 2.5%
Warwick Saupold 10% 2.5%
Drew Verhagen 15% 5%
Non-roster lefties:
Kenny Faulk 10% 2.5%
Blaine Hardy 25% 7.5%
Matt Hoffmann 35% 12.5%
Robbie Ray 10% 2.5%

Sure, there's endless opportunity to quibble with my numbers for one player or another, but I've tried my best not to be overly optimistic or pessimistic in general. If I've succeeded, there should be some merit to my conclusion. The Tigers bullpen may not be elite in 2014, but I contend that we might expect average performance or even a little better (albeit with a high degree of uncertainty!). Combined with a still-outstanding rotation and a fairly formidable offense, the Tigers may still have about as good a chance as anyone else at capturing that elusive title.

Now it's your turn to tell me how crazy I am. Or, you can paste this thing into your own spreadsheet and tell us what answers you get (do that and you'll get a free Detroit Tigers numbers geek lapel pin! least in a virtual sense). If nothing else, it passes the time until we get to see how the Tigers reliever roulette pans out in 2014.

This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of the <em>Bless You Boys</em> writing staff.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

Join Bless You Boys

You must be a member of Bless You Boys to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Bless You Boys. You should read them.

Join Bless You Boys

You must be a member of Bless You Boys to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Bless You Boys. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.