clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Was Leyland right with his 'they're due' comment?

New, 16 comments

Yesterday, Tigers manager Jim Leyland played four players -- Austin Jackson, Jhonny Peralta, Brandon Inge, and Casper Wells -- who were a combined 4-for-51 off Bruce Chen.

Jackson was 1-for-9, Peralta 2-for-14, Inge 1-for-21 and Wells 0-for-7 heading into the game.

Why did he go counter to the small-sample size stats he usually relies on to make his decisions? He told the media:

"Shows how smart I am. ... The way I look at it, they're due."

So let's see how due they really were. Yesterday against Chen, they were a combined ... 1-for-9 with four strikeouts.

Ouch. I guess they weren't so due after all. If only Leyland had said, "I don't make lineup decisions based on a handful of at-bats against a certain pitcher" we'd be heralding his saberness today, but instead he says they're due and proves Joe Morgan's frequent thesis wrong again.

Here's how the individuals did in their at bats against Chen:

Jackson

First inning -- Strikes out swinging

Third inning -- Fly out to right field

Sixth inning -- Grounds out to pitcher

Peralta

Second inning -- Fly out to left field

Fifth inning -- Strikes out swinging

Inge

Third inning -- Strikeout on a foul tip

Fifth inning -- Strikes out on a foul tip

Wells

Third inning -- Singles to center field

Sixth inning -- Pops out to first baseman