clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Blue Jays 7, Tigers 3: Verlander and offense come up short, the never-ending funk continues with fifth straight loss

The Tornto Blue Jays rode three home runs to a 7-3 win over the badly slumping Detroit Tigers. The Tigers have lost a season high five in a row, 7-of-10 and 13-of-17.

Rick Osentoski-USA TODAY Sports

The Detroit Tigers' latest losing streak reached a season high five games thanks to 7-3 loss to the surging Toronto Blue Jays. The last three weeks for the Tigers have been a train wreck, losing 13-of-17. The Blue Jays have been the polar opposite, now victorious in 18 of their past 22 games.

J.A. Happ (W, 5-2) was the starter and winner for the Blue Jays, allowing three runs on seven hits over 6 1/3 innings. The Blue Jays' bullpen shut down the Tigers for a second straight game. Chad Jenkins tossed 2 1/3 scoreless innings, closer Casey Janssen nailing down the final out.

"We're not doing anything very well. It's been one thing, another thing or a combination." -Brad Ausmus

It was hoped Justin Verlander (L, 6-5) had regained his form after a solid start against the Mariners. Despite Verlander's claims he was happy with his stuff, the Blue Jays got to him for six runs, five earned,and eight hits over seven innings. Verlander's ERA resides at a season high 4.14 after today's loss. Phil Coke did more Phil Coke things, surrendering a ninth inning home run to make for the final margin.

The Blue Jays did the majority of their damage in two innings, scoring three runs in both the fourth and sixth. Dioner Navarro kicked off the scoring with an RBI single, Erik Kratz following with a two RBI single. Juan Francisco and Brett Lawrie both hit their tenth home runs of the season in back-to-back at-bats in the sixth. Melky Cabrera's solo shot in the ninth, also number ten on the year, accounted for the remainder of the Blue Jays' scoring.

Ian Kinsler led the Tigers' meager offensive attack with two hits and two RBIs. Nick Castellanos had three hits and scored a run.

When the Tigers left Boston three weeks ago, they were a season high 15 games over .500 at 27-12. They've given nine of those games back over the past 17, today's loss lowering the Tigers to six games over .500 at 31-25.

I'm at a loss to explain it. It remains to be seen which is the real Tigers team - the one which started 27-12, or the one currently on a 4-13 skid.

Justin Verlander pitched into, then out of, trouble in the top of the first. Singles by Jose Reyes and Jose Bautista put runners on the corners with one out. Verlander waded though troubled waters to get out of the inning unscathed. Adam Lind, last night's offensive catalyst for the Blue Jays, popped up to third, Juan Francisco ending the inning with a fly ball to left.

Neither team could mount a threat for the next couple of innings, Verlander and J.A. Happ exchanging scoreless frames.

Bottom of three, Nick Castellanos became the first Tiger to advance past first base, leading off by doubling off the left field fence. Andrew Romine moved him over with a ground ball to the right side.

Then the Tigers caught a break, allowing them to draw first blood.

Melky Cabrera's failed attempt at a diving catch on Ian Kinsler's bloop to short left drove in Castellanos. The ball rolled far enough away from Cabrera to allow a hustling Kinsler to race all the way to third, credited with one of the shorter RBI triples you'll ever see ( video).

Kinsler's hustle paid off with a second run, scoring on Torii Hunter's sacrifice fly to center field.

Unfortunately for the Tigers, horrific outfield defense gave the Blue Jays an unexpected scoring opportunity. Jackson and Hunter failed to communicate on Bautista's pop fly to short right center. The result was an awkward misplay which allowed the ball to drop for a brutal two-base error, which was charged to Hunter.

Verlander compounded the error by giving up a single to Lind and walking Francisco, loading the bases with one out.

Unlike the Tigers last night, the Blue Jays were able to capitalize with the bases full. Dioner Navarro slapped a single to left, everyone moving forward 90 feet. Light-hitting catcher Erik Kratz gave the Blue Jays the lead with a ground ball single through the left side, plating two more runs.

Verlander did get the double play he needed, but it was one batter too late. The Blue Jays' rally petered out when Romine turned Anthony Gose's ground ball into a 6-3 twin killing. But the Blue Jays had taken a three run lead, one of the runs unearned thanks to Hunter and Jackson lacking communication skills.

The bottom of the fourth had more questionable tactics by the Tigers, over-aggressiveness on the bases leading to outs. One down, J.D. Martinez was caught stealing with Jackson at the plate, taking the Tigers out of the inning.

Bottom of five, Happ surrendered back-to-back singles to Alex Avila and Castellanos. Romine tried the "fake a bunt, then take a choppy swing" maneuver. The resulting slow roller to third worked just a well as a straight sacrifice bunt.

Both runners now in scoring position, Kinsler knotted the game at 3-all with an RBI ground out to short. That's where the rally would end, Hunter flying out to right.

Verlander immediately gave the lead right back. Lind drew a lead off walk, Verlander then serving up a no-doubt two run shot to Francisco, Hunter watching the ball sail over the right field wall. The tenth home run of the season for Francisco gave the Blue Jays a 5-3 lead.

The inning went completely sideways for Verlander when Brett Lawrie yanked a 93 MPH fastball over the bullpens in left. Lawrie's tenth big fly of the season increased the Blue Jays' lead to 6-3.

The Tigers' offense remained in their brutal funk in the bottom of the sixth. The Tigers only sent three to the plate, J.D. Martinez bouncing into a double play to end another scoreless inning.

"It's a good baseball team that's not playing good baseball right now." -Brad Ausmus

Top of seven, Verlander was still on the mound for Detroit. He allowed a single and steal of second to Bautista (who got such a huge jump, Avila's throw was more for show than anything else). Verlander would get out of the inning, but his frustrating afternoon was over after 107 pitches and five earned runs.

Happ ended his far more effective appearance with one out in the seventh and having thrown 106 pitches. Manager John Gibbons pulled his starter, replacing him with right-hander Chad Jenkins.

Castellanos greeted Jenkins by singling to left, bringing the tying run to the plate in ... oh, yeah ... Romine. The struggling shortstop dribbled a comebacker on the first pitch, Jenkins starting an easy 1-6-3 inning ending double play, the third of the afternoon.

The Tigers' bullpen was a mixed bag. Evan Reed took over from Verlander in the eighth, walking one in a scoreless frame. But Phil Coke made another unimpressive appearance, dishing out a solo home run to Melky Cabrera in the top of the ninth. The third home run of the game for the Blue Jays pushed their lead to what would be the final score, 7-3.

Bottom of the ninth, the Tigers took their last offensive gasp when Jackson singled and Avila walked. Not wanting to mess around, Gibbons brought in his closer, Casey Janssen. He didn't even need to break a sweat. Castellanos lined out to left on the first pitch, ending another miserable day for the Tigers.

Game over. Your final score is Blue Jays 7, Tigers 3.

Last night Brad Ausmus said "This isn't Armageddon" when quizzed about the Tigers' recent slide. After today's ugly loss, let the "Armageddon" memes begin.

Looking to avenge getting swept three weeks ago, the Red Sox arrive in Detroit for a three game weekend series. Reclamation project Rubby De La Rosa get his second start as a member of the Red Sox, Drew Smyly takes the mound for the Tigers.

In 2012, De La Rosa was the final piece part of the huge Dodgers - Red Sox trade. He didn't pitch well after being called up late last season (5.56 ERA in 11 1/3 innings). In need of a starter to replace an injured Clay Buchholz, a 3.04 ERA with Triple-A Pawtucket this season earned the 25-year-old another call up. De La Rosa's first start was an impressive one, shutting out the Rays on four hits, while striking out eight over seven innings.

Smyly is mired in a slump, having gone winless for more than a month. Over his last six appearances, including one in relief, Smyly is 0-3 with a 5.47 ERA. His last start was just more of the same, pulled after allowing three runs on seven hits, tossing 105 pitches over four innings in a loss to the Mariners.

Friday night's first pitch is set for 7:08 PM.


Source: FanGraphs


Eugenio Suarez was supposed to make his first career start today, but a sore knee is keeping him out of the lineup. The injury occurred Wednesday night, thanks to one of the worst slides you'll ever see.


An MRI showed no structural damage. According to Brad Ausmus, the team will re-evaluate the shortstop position based on how Suarez feels on Friday. Currently, Don Kelly is the only other backup option at shortstop. If the Tigers had extended the ninth inning one more at-bat, Kelly would have pinch-hit for Andrew Romine. Ausmus confirmed Kelly would have remained in the game as the shortstop if the Tigers had mounted a comeback.

The Tigers' recent struggles can be encapsulated in one spreadsheet.

When 2/3 of your starting outfield has a worse OPS than Romine, is it any surprise the Tigers are scuffling badly at the plate?

As for the pitching?

How inconsistent has the offense been? This inconsistent:

How bad has the offense been? This bad:

If this funk continues, we may be handling snakes next.


Austin Jackson snapped an 0-for-10 skein with a second inning single, ending the day with two hits and a walk. The last time Jackson reached base more than twice was back on May 9.

By allowing back-to-back home runs in the sixth, it was the first time Justin Verlander allowed two home runs in a game this season. It's also the first time he's given up back-to-back jacks since 2012.

Over his last six games, Torii Hunter is 2-for-22 with a sacrifice fly.

The loss drops the Tigers to 14-14 at Comerica Park. Their five straight home losses is the longest streak since 2008.


Nick Castellanos: Three hits and a fine defensive play for the rookie third baseman. It was the second three hit game of the season for Castellanos.

Ian Kinsler: Two hits drove home two of the Tigers' three runs.

Asutin Jackson: Reached base three times on two singles and a base on balls.


Justin Verlander: Post-game, Brad Ausmus said Verlander's "stuff was outstanding." Not helping was some questionable defense. But that had nothing to with his serving up a pair of home runs or issuing a season high four walks.

Torii Hunter: Did drive in a run with a fly ball, but did nothing else. The Tigers could afford to carry Hunter's rapidly declining defense when he was hitting. But Hunter stopped hitting a month ago. Hunter's OPS topped out at .885 on May 6. Entering today's action, Hunter was "hitting" .187/.221/.352, an OPS of .573 over his last 24 games. That's 53 points lower than Don Kelly over the same time frame.

J.D. Martinez: The all-or-nothing Martinez gave nothing today, 0-for-4 with a strikeout and a GIDP. The Tigers' outfield has been awful in all phases of the game for the past month.


Miguel Cabrera: It's the rare day when Cabrera is invisible. Today was one of those rare days - 0-for-4 with two ground ball outs.


Total comments 719
Total commenters 53
Commenter list Allison Hagen, Bent82, Cabbylander, Combo Guard City, Designated for Assignment, Detroit Larry, Fielder'sChoice, Fu-Te Ni-ekro, House by the Side of the Road, JWurm, J_the_Man, Jacob30, Jim Bunn, LoganB, MSUDersh, NCDee, Naqamel, Naysayer N San Diego, Nonsuch Ned, Rafael Tigers, RoverTO, SabreRoseTiger, SanDiegoMick, Sean Heyboer, SeeingEyeDouble, ShowingBunt, Singledigit, SpartanHT, Thorpac, Tigerdog1, ahtrap, bobrob2004, dand3, dimes5, dishnet34, dominator039, draykov44, ja_zz, japobere, jgrubbs, jippolito, knucklescarbone, kstil1505, lesmanalim, lithium, longview, loswr86, matts1022, nicolas08, radivel, snizo, stevenyc, subic sailor
Story URLs


# Commenter # Comments
1 SabreRoseTiger 90
2 SanDiegoMick 69
3 Singledigit 54
4 bobrob2004 42
5 J_the_Man 36
6 Fielder'sChoice 32
7 SpartanHT 27
8 stevenyc 27
9 Rafael Tigers 23
10 Jacob30 22


# Recs Commenter Comment Link
5 Fielder'sChoice Meatless....burgers?
3 Singledigit [no title]
3 Nonsuch Ned [no title]
3 dominator039 this made me laugh, i think a lot of us could use a laugh right now
2 Fielder'sChoice backbackbackbackbackbackbackback


Rick Porcello didn't get the win, but did take PotG with 85% of the vote.