clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Detroit Tigers links: Don't move in the fences at Comerica Park

New, 26 comments

After some deep outs from J.D. Martinez, the ballpark dimension debate is back on.

Tim Fuller-USA TODAY Sports

Its an interesting concept when thought about in relation to other sports. Every major league baseball team gets to design their home field dimensions in whatever manner they want. Can you imagine this being the case in any other sport? The Joe Louis backboards ending right next to the goal. The Lions making their field 200 yards so that they could highlight their best player Jason Hanson. Absolutely inconceivable.

In baseball, unique stadium dimensions is just another quirk of the sport, like the DH or the All Star game providing home field advantage. And the Tigers have theirs designed to provide pitchers a distinct advantage. Outside of Houston's absurd 435 foot center field semi circle, Comerica Park has the deepest center field in the majors at 420 feet (most stadiums are around 400). Additionally, left and right center are deep and include a high fence in right center. There is a lot of grass out there.

Because of these vast expanses, there has been an intermittent debate about whether the fences should be moved in to provide prolific hitters such as Miguel Cabrera and Victor Martinez more places to hit the ball into the stands. The debate was sparked again when JD Martinez, who is trying to become only the 6th Tiger to hit 40 home runs, had 2 home runs robbed by Comerica's dimensions Friday Night. Lynn Henning of the Detroit News lobbied for a redesign of both the outfield fences and center field in general to remedy the issue.

I don't disagree with Lynn's point that additional architecture could enhance the outfield set up. But Comerica Park is already considered one of the nicer ballparks in access and visual aesthetics. And I've grown to love the pitching friendly aspects of the park. Watching Austin Jackson and Curtis Granderson make countless breathtaking plays gave me an appreciation for the sheer size. It may stunt some of Miggy's hall of fame credentials, but it provides highlight reel defense and offers Tigers' pitching with protection, something that its many fly ball pitchers have required.

I'm firmly on the side of keeping the fences where they are, but I'm interested in what the Bless You Boys faithful think. Keep them deep or move them in?

Detroit Tigers could be forced to call up more relievers to aid taxed bullpen - MLive.com, James Schmehl
The Tigers have taken full advantage of the expanded rosters, having called up all but two pitchers on their current 40-man roster. The problem? They may still be short. This won't end well.

Tigers' Matt Boyd likes progress of his two-seam fastball - Detroit Free Press, Anthony Fenech
Matt Boyd, approaching his inning limit, is seeing positive progress in his sinking two-seam fastball.

Bruce Rondon has the most to prove of any Tigers youngster in season’s final two weeks - Oakland Press, Matthew Mowery
Bruce Rondon has been the heir apparent for the closer role but has done nothing to prove that he is ready for it.

A Discussion With Baseball Revolutionaries, Billy Beane and Bill James - Wall Street Journal, Brian Costa
Oakland Athletics general manager Billy Beane and statistical wizard Bill James are two major catalysts behind the data-driven MLB—yet their paths have seldom overlapped.

The worst month of Chris Sale's career - Beyond the Box Score, Matt Goldman
Chris Sale has made four starts since September first, and the results haven't been pretty.

Postseason Rotations and Matching Up Aces - FanGraphs Baseball, Roger Cheng
Taking a look at the best way to set up your pitching staff to succeed in the playoffs.